Just some thoughts on horror to keep the blog clinging to life until I get some stories up and start posting regularly.
I was reading a new book this morning lent to me by a friend. It got me to thinking a bit about the author’s style. I’ve read several of his other books, and I keep coming away with total ambivalence. On the one hand, I think he’s got something going, a certain Je ne sais quoi. I like the characters he creates, and I think the interactions come across as genuine, which is a tough thing to pull off when you’re trying to move a story along.
I also like his personality. He’s got a sort of high-school bad attitude thing going on in his writing that speaks to me. It’s like, in his world, there’s always a 17-year-old wearing a leather jacket with spikes on the shoulders and smoking a cigarette behind the 7-11. It’s like distilling all of the angst and aggression from early 90s punk and mixing it with a touch of disappointment in the world.
On the other hand, like a rebellious teenager, you’re really supposed to either grow out of that, or refine it to a more sophisticated worldview, by the time you’re in your, say, mid-20s. A moody 19-year-old with piercings is dangerous and cool; a moody 32-year-old with piercings is a little sad, and more than a little annoying.
Which brings me to horror.
It goes without saying that this is strictly my opinion, which means that it’s the opinion of an unpublished amateur. My experience, aside from unpublished stories, begins and ends with being a consumer of horror fiction across several media. As someone who is trying to get published, I have nothing but respect and admiration for anyone who has successfully been published. That said, I have developed certain preferences regarding horror.
Good horror is running into a dark room, locking the door behind you, and hearing a dog growl softly. Good horror is waking up with a rattlesnake in your sleeping bag. Good horror whispers and walks, because it knows you have nowhere to go, and it wants to have a little fun before it gets down to business.
There is a school of thought practiced by many writers, some of whom are very, very famous (Mr. King, lookin’ at you here), which says that horror can also be the gross-out, the shock, and the gore. It says that, if you can’t or won’t get the spooky, intellectual scare, just go for the cringe. Go for the grimace. You can’t use too many colorful obscenities, and you can’t detail enough gore. Scares are great, but discomfort’s good, too.
Eli Roth has made a serious career by making films that skip scary and go straight for gory. Take “Hostel”, for example. It’s basically a feature film of watching someone have a tooth pulled without anesthetic. It’s torture-porn. There’s no subtlety, no slow build of suspense, no sense of dread. It’s the narrative equivalent of a fart joke. Now, as someone who has seen every single Three Stooges short, I can appreciate a good fart joke, but it ain’t horror.
Gratuitous profanity is the verbal equivalent of a slasher flick, and more than a few authors have used torrents of profanity to shock readers (again, King is one of the more noteworthy offenders). The idea is, of course, to play off of the tension and discomfort that offensive language causes in certain situations. Maybe some people dig it. I don’t. I find it to be annoying rather than disconcerting. Maybe because I have such an intimate relationship with the most grievous obscenities in my daily vocabulary I’m just not impressed by its use in other contexts. Like hearing an obnoxious teenager yell “vagina” in a convenience store, I’m not shocked, just sympathetically embarrassed.
It’s bad horror, and that’s what bothers me. If good horror is waking up in a coffin, bad horror is being kicked in the shins by a young child. Bad horror is a blaring alarm clock that you can’t turn off. It’s an exploding cigar, a whoopee cushion, a flaming bag of dog shit sitting on your front porch.
Now, just like there’s a time and a place for Cap’n Crunch, and a time and a place for Steak au Poivre, there’s a time and a place for bad horror. Schlocky slasher flicks can be a lot of fun. God knows Italian guignol horror thrives on over-the-top gore, and does it really, really well. But it’s not what I consider horror.
I’ll bring this ramble to a close by reiterating that there is absolutely no reason to take anything I’ve just written to heart. I have no publishing credits to my name. I’m a fan of the genre, and an aspiring amateur writer. That’s it. So besides the obviously self-congratulatory nature of blogging, the other reason I’m writing about this is almost as a reminder to myself. I can and have written gore, but I’m aiming for something better, something that will stick with my readers, hiding out in a corner of their heads, waiting until it’s been forgotten. Waiting until the dark, early hours of the morning to whisper, “Finally, now we can be alone together…”
